Reciprocating Saw Showdown: RYOBI vs. DEWALT for Your Toughest Jobs

When it comes to demolition, pruning, or making quick cuts through tough materials, a reciprocating saw is an indispensable tool. But with so many options on the market, choosing the right one can feel overwhelming. We put four popular models from RYOBI and DEWALT to the test, examining their performance, features, and overall value to help you make an informed decision for your next project. Our lineup includes two corded options and two battery-powered saws, offering a range of power and portability.

Quick Specs at a Glance

Here's a quick look at how these reciprocating saws stack up on paper:

| Product | Brand | Price | Rating (Avg/Reviews) | Power Source | | -------------------------------------------------------- | ------ | ------- | -------------------- | --------------------------- | | 12 Amp Corded Reciprocating Saw | RYOBI | $89.00 | 4.24/5 (1437) | Corded Electric | | 20V MAX Cordless Reciprocating Saw (Tool Only) | DEWALT | $159.00 | 4.60/5 (15049) | Cordless (20V MAX Battery) | | ONE+ 18V Cordless Reciprocating Saw (Tool Only) | RYOBI | $49.97 | 4.59/5 (2227) | Cordless (18V ONE+ Battery) | | 20V MAX Cordless Brushless Reciprocating Saw (Tool Only) | DEWALT | $229.00 | 4.66/5 (545) | Cordless (20V MAX Battery) |

Feature Face-Off: Power, Ergonomics, and Versatility

We focused on how each saw handles common tasks, from cutting through lumber to metal pipes and even tree branches.

Cutting Power and Speed

When raw power is the priority, corded saws often have an edge, and the RYOBI 12 Amp Corded Reciprocating Saw delivers a solid punch for its price point. It chews through 2x4s with relative ease and can handle occasional metal cutting. However, it lacks the sustained power and speed of the premium cordless options. The DEWALT 20V MAX Cordless Brushless Reciprocating Saw is the undisputed champion in this category. Its brushless motor provides exceptional power and efficiency, making quick work of even demanding cuts. The standard DEWALT 20V MAX Cordless Reciprocating Saw is also very capable, offering a good balance of power and portability. The RYOBI ONE+ 18V Cordless Reciprocating Saw is surprisingly competent for its low price, tackling most DIY tasks without complaint, though it might bog down on the most challenging materials compared to the DEWALT models.

Ergonomics and Comfort

A reciprocating saw can vibrate heavily, and comfort is key for extended use. The RYOBI models, both corded and cordless, are generally comfortable to hold, with well-placed grips. However, they can feel a bit less refined than their DEWALT counterparts. The DEWALT saws excel in this area. The DEWALT 20V MAX Cordless Brushless Reciprocating Saw, in particular, boasts excellent vibration control, making it a pleasure to use even for prolonged periods. The standard 20V MAX model also offers a comfortable grip and balanced feel. For users who frequently find themselves with a reciprocating saw in hand, the reduction in fatigue from the DEWALT models is a significant advantage.

Blade Versatility and Blade Change

All four saws feature tool-free blade changes, a crucial convenience that saves time and frustration on the job. This allows for quick swaps between wood, metal, or demolition blades as needed. In terms of compatibility, all standard reciprocating saw blades will fit these models.

Corded vs. Cordless Convenience

The choice between corded and cordless is often the biggest deciding factor. The RYOBI 12 Amp Corded Reciprocating Saw offers unlimited runtime as long as you have a power outlet, making it ideal for stationary work or long demolition sessions where battery life isn't a concern. However, the cord can be cumbersome and limits your reach. The cordless DEWALT and RYOBI saws offer unparalleled freedom of movement. You can take them anywhere, from the attic to the backyard, without worrying about an extension cord. The RYOBI ONE+ 18V is particularly attractive for homeowners already invested in the ONE+ battery system, as it leverages existing batteries. The DEWALT 20V MAX platform offers robust performance, but you'll need to factor in the cost of batteries and chargers if you're new to the system.

Price and Value Analysis

This is where the lines between these saws become very clear. The RYOBI ONE+ 18V Cordless Reciprocating Saw at $49.97 is an absolute steal, especially if you already own RYOBI 18V ONE+ batteries. It offers excellent cordless convenience and capable performance for a remarkably low entry price. The RYOBI 12 Amp Corded Reciprocating Saw ($89.00) is a budget-friendly corded option. It provides good power for its price, but the cord limits its versatility. The DEWALT 20V MAX Cordless Reciprocating Saw (Tool Only) at $159.00 represents a solid mid-range cordless choice. Its performance is strong, and it benefits from DEWALT's reputation for durability. However, the "tool only" price means you'll need to add batteries and a charger, increasing the overall investment. The DEWALT 20V MAX Cordless Brushless Reciprocating Saw (Tool Only) ($229.00) is the premium option. While it's the most expensive, its superior power, efficiency, and comfort justify the cost for professionals or serious DIYers who demand the best.

Who Should Buy Which Saw?

* **Best Budget Cordless Option:** The RYOBI ONE+ 18V Cordless Reciprocating Saw is the clear winner here. If you're on a tight budget and already own RYOBI 18V ONE+ batteries, this saw offers incredible value and cordless freedom for general DIY tasks. * **Best Budget Corded Option:** The RYOBI 12 Amp Corded Reciprocating Saw is a practical choice for those who don't need cordless mobility and want reliable power without breaking the bank. It's great for workshop use or projects near an outlet. * **Best All-Around Cordless for Most Users:** The DEWALT 20V MAX Cordless Reciprocating Saw (Tool Only) hits a sweet spot. It offers excellent performance, robust build quality, and the convenience of cordless operation. While the initial cost is higher than RYOBI, its longevity and power make it a worthwhile investment for frequent use. * **Best Premium Cordless for Professionals and Heavy-Duty Users:** The DEWALT 20V MAX Cordless Brushless Reciprocating Saw (Tool Only) is the top performer. If you need maximum power, efficiency, and comfort for demanding jobs, this saw is worth every penny. Its brushless motor and advanced design make it a powerful tool for any serious tradesperson.

Final Verdict

For the average homeowner tackling occasional projects, the RYOBI ONE+ 18V Cordless Reciprocating Saw is the standout value proposition. Its low price and cordless convenience are hard to beat, especially for those already in the RYOBI ecosystem. However, if you're looking for a more robust, durable, and powerful tool that will stand up to more frequent and demanding use, the DEWALT offerings are superior. The DEWALT 20V MAX Cordless Reciprocating Saw (Tool Only) is our recommendation for the best all-around cordless choice for most users due to its excellent balance of performance, build quality, and user comfort. For professionals who need the absolute best, the premium brushless DEWALT model is the way to go.